Alexander Sanger to be biologically pro-life, one must be politically pro-choice
Home Bio Book The Sanger File Contact
Jailed for Birth Control
Entrapment, then jail for birth control? Not for abortion, for birth control? The idea would be ludicrous if not for the recent use of entrapment and edited videos trying to establish the 'guilt' of family planning providers allegedly 'selling' fetal remains after legal abortions. The attack here is on family planning providers, and Planned Parenthood in particular, with Congress and state legislatures trying eliminate their funding, thereby forcing Planned Parenthood to close its doors and stop serving patients unable to pay. 
I fear a world where poor women are back to where they were 100 years ago, when the only available methods were uncertain diaphragms, and more uncertain recipes for douches and suppositories, and, of course, withdrawal and the male condom, thus giving men, not women, control of reproduction, which is the ultimate goal of abortion opponents.
There is a sordid history to entrapment being used against advocates of reproductive freedom.
One hundred years ago, opponents of legal birth control had succeeded in passing laws outlawing all methods to prevent conception, as well as any speech advocating the legalization thereof. These laws, called the Comstock Laws, named after Anthony Comstock, the nation's leading anti-vice crusader, were enacted before my grandmother, Margaret Sanger, coined the term, 'birth control' in 1914 in her newspaper, The Woman Rebel. This anarchist paper, for a variety of reasons, raised the ire of the authorities, and in October 1914 she was indicted, among other counts, for violating the nation's Comstock Laws for advocating the legalization of birth control. She never actually gave any birth control information in the paper, but, before fleeing to Europe to avoid being railroaded to jail for her advocacy, she penned a 16-page pamphlet, Family Limitation, which gave information on various douches, suppositories and other rudimentary methods of the day.
Anthony Comstock was not amused. In January 1915, he sent an undercover police officer to the architectural office of my grandfather, William Sanger, who was estranged from, but still legally married to, my grandmother. The officer, claiming to be a Mr. Heller and a colleague of my grandmother, asked for one of her pamphlets in order to translate it into several languages to distribute among the poor. My grandfather believed this tale and, rummaging through my grandmother's belongings, which she had left behind in her hasty departure, found a copy of Family Limitation, delivered it to Mr. Heller and was arrested for violating the Comstock Laws. 
William Sanger, 1912. Credit: Alexander Sanger
The New York Comstock Law prohibited: "uttering an advertisement purporting to give information where, how, when, of who, and by what means an article purporting to be for immoral use, could be obtained." Contraception was "immoral" under the law, and thus illegal. Not surprisingly, condoms were not illegal, since they could be used for the cure or prevention of venereal disease; only women-controlled methods were illegal.
Comstock offered my grandfather a deal: I'll drop the charges if you tell me where your wife is. Even though estranged, my grandfather was ever hopeful of reconciliation and refused to turn his wife in. 
Before trial William Sanger made a prescient statement: "I deny the right of the state any longer to encroach on the privacy of the individual by invading it with this statute. I deny the right of the state to exercise dominion over the souls and bodies of our women by compelling them to go into unwilling motherhood."
On September 10, 1915, my grandfather went to trial before a three-judge criminal court, having been denied a jury trial. He freely admitted handing over the pamphlet but then declared that the law and not he was on trial. He went on to call Comstock a "religious and pornographic fanatic" and "the victim of incurable sexophobia." He continued, "I deny the right of the state to encroach on the rights of the individual by invading the most private and fundamental relations of men and women." Fifty years later, the US Supreme Court in Griswold v. Connecticut would use similar language to overturn the last of the nation's Comstock Laws.
But my grandfather was ahead of his time and was found guilty. But more, he was a threat to the moral order of things. "Such persons as you who circulate such pamphlets are a menace to society," said Justice McInerney. "There are too many now who consider it a crime to have children. If some of the women who go around advocating equal suffrage would go around and advocate women having children they would do a greater service."
My grandfather was given a choice of $150 fine or 30 days in jail. He chose jail. "I will never pay that fine. I would rather be in jail for my conviction than to be free at a loss of my manhood and my self respect." My grandfather's supporters erupted in protest and the court was cleared.
Thus the first person put in jail in my grandmother's birth control crusade was not my grandmother, it was my grandfather. More importantly, the trial and sentence aroused the conscience of the nation, Anthony Comstock became a laughing stock, and his laws were doomed to be ignored, repealed or overturned.
Entrapment of reproductive freedom advocates will fail. Civil disobedient women in the future will go to jail for taking the Pill, and, judges, like Justice McInerney, will lecture them on their duty to have children and submit to their husbands. There aren't jails enough in this country to hold the women who would rather be in jail with their womanhood and self-respect intact than be told what to do with their bodies and their lives.
» Link to this post
My First Opera
My First Opera - in the Fall 2015 issue of Opera America
» Link to this post

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

Alexander Sanger
Alexander C. Sanger, the grandson of Margaret Sanger, who founded the birth control movement over eighty years ago, is currently Chair of the International Planned Parenthood Council.
Mr. Sanger previously served as the President of Planned Parenthood of New York City (PPNYC) and its international arm, The Margaret Sanger Center International (MSCI) for ten years from 1991 - 2000.

Mr. Sanger speaks around the country and the world and has served as a Goodwill Ambassador for the United Nations Population Fund.

Beyond Choice
Beyond Choice
The new book by Alexander Sanger published by PublicAffairs

Purchase from

Click here for full book information

With reproductive freedom in jeopardy, Alexander Sanger, grandson of renowned family planning advocate Margaret Sanger and a longtime leader in the reproductive rights movement, has taken an urgent, fresh look at the pro-choice position—and even the pro-life position—and finds them necessary, but insufficient. In Beyond Choice he offers the first major re-thinking of these positions in thirty years.

“Well researched and readable, Beyond Choice should be required reading for both pro-choice and pro-life supporters.”
—Governor Christine Todd Whitman


» Much more on Beyond Choice, including an excerpt, discussion guides, reviews
The Sanger List
Sign up to receive updates and news from Alexander Sanger
External Links
» Eugenics, Race, and Margaret sanger Revisited: Reproductive Freedom for All?
Hypatia, Indiana University Press
Recent Press
» Abortion in the Spotlight [PDF]
Tina Morlock, Oklahoma City Pioneer

» Advocate: Abortion does involve morality
Paul Swiech, The Pantagraph

» Planned Parenthood founder: Republican Party is pro-choice
Elaine Hopkins, The Journal Star

» Women's Studies seminar covers controversial topic
Jamie Smith, The Daily Vidette

» Luncheon promotes teen responsibility
Dahlia Weinstein, Rocky Mountain News
Blog Archives
» January 2004
» February 2004
» March 2004
» April 2004
» May 2004
» July 2004
» September 2004
» October 2004
» November 2004
» December 2004
» February 2005
» March 2005
» April 2005
» June 2005
» July 2005
» September 2005
» October 2005
» November 2005
» December 2005
» January 2006
» February 2006
» March 2006
» April 2006
» June 2006
» November 2006
» February 2007
» July 2007
» September 2007
» November 2007
» January 2008
» February 2008
» March 2008
» May 2008
» September 2008
» October 2008
» December 2008
» June 2009
» July 2009
» September 2009
» October 2009
» November 2009
» January 2010
» February 2010
» April 2010
» May 2010
» October 2010
» November 2010
» December 2010
» January 2011
» February 2011
» May 2011
» July 2011
» October 2011
» November 2011
» December 2011
» February 2012
» April 2012
» June 2012
» September 2012
» October 2012
» January 2013
» February 2013
» April 2013
» May 2013
» June 2013
» July 2013
» November 2013
» January 2014
» March 2014
» May 2014
» July 2014
» December 2014
» March 2015
» April 2015
» May 2015
» June 2015
» July 2015
» September 2015
» October 2015
» December 2015
» January 2016
» February 2016
» April 2016
» May 2016
» June 2016
» August 2016
» October 2016
» November 2016
» December 2016
» January 2017
» February 2017
» March 2017

 Subscribe in a reader
External Links
» International Planned Parenthood Federation/Western Hemisphere Region

» UN Goodwill Ambassadors

» The Margaret Sanger Papers Project, NYU History Dept.

» When Sex Counts: Making Babies and Making Law, by Sherry Colb